Comparative Migration Studies, Vol. 5, No. 4
Commentary series: Multiculturalism-Interculturalism
Ever since the 1980s-1990s, multiculturalism has had both its advocates and its critics. While the support long outweighed the critique, the tide seemed to change at the beginning of the new millennium. Critical voices have become more numerous and vigorous. The critiques have increasingly merged into a growing chorus of concern and a popular refrain about the failure, decline and even death of multiculturalism. While ‘multiculturalism’ has become the proverbial punching bag, ‘interculturalism’ has been increasingly put forward as a distinct and much welcome alternative. In this Special Issue, edited by François Levrau and Patrick Loobuyck, original perspectives are brought together aiming to clarify and advance the ‘Multiculturalism-Interculturalism Debate’. To what extent does interculturalism provide a different approach to deal with ethno-cultural diversity? Does it complement multiculturalism or is it just a relabelling that does not go beyond selling old wine in new bottles? Tariq Modood and Ricard Zapata-Barrero, two of the leading proponents of this debate, each provide a seperate and independent key text which will be critically assessed by 6 guest authors: Tamar de Waal, Christian Joppke, Riva Kastoryano, François Levrau, Jocelyn Maclure and Stijn Oosterlynck.
Introduction: mapping the multiculturalism-interculturalism debate
Since the 1970s multiculturalist policies that recognize and accommodate ethnocultural diversity have been implemented across western democracies.
François LevrauEmail author and Patrick Loobuyck
Main articles in this comment series:
Interculturalism in the post-multicultural debate: a defence
- War of words: interculturalism v. multiculturalism
- Is the post-multicultural era pro-diversity?
Tamar de Waal
- Moving the debate forward: interculturalism’s contribution to multiculturalism
François Boucher and Jocelyn Maclure
- Moving beyond normative philosophies and policy concerns: a sociological account of place-based solidarities in diversity
- Towards a new way of interacting? Pondering the role of an interpersonal ethos
- Multiculturalism and interculturalism: redefining nationhood and solidarity
- Multiculturalism and interculturalism: alongside but separate
- Interculturalism: Not a new policy paradigm